Saturday, August 2, 2025

Are They Gifts or Talents

I have mentioned the importance of spiritual gifts to the health of the church on several occasions. (See Related Posts) The most critical passage may be in Paul’s letter to the Corinthians where he asserts that every believer is given a gift by the Holy Spirit. I have lamented the fact that many believers haven’t a clue what their gift is. This unfortunate situation may well explain why the church is in such a sorry state. The Scripture is clear that spiritual gifts are given for the building and maturing the Body of Christ. Human effort will not accomplish what only God can do through His empowerment of believers.

Beginning with the assumption that spiritual gifts are necessary for the health of Christ’s body, it follows that a clear understanding of those gifts is essential. First, we have to see that the gifts come from God. In Ephesians, Paul says that Christ gave gifts to the church; in Corinthians it is the Holy Spirit who distributes the gifts. This is not a contradiction because we understand that although we speak of God being three in one, He is one in purpose. Spiritual gifts clearly come from God.

Second, we learn that it is God who determines what gifts each believer is granted. In Romans, Paul says some have one gift and some another; the passage in Ephesians is worded similarly. It is most clearly stated in the Corinthian passage: “But in all these things one and the same Spirit is at work, distributing to each one individually just as he wishes.” God knows best what each local assembly needs to fulfill its purpose, so He provides the spiritual power to accomplish His will.

Third, and perhaps most importantly, we see that spiritual gifts are not given for the benefit of the receiver; they are meant to benefit the whole body. To the Ephesians Paul says gifts are: “for the equipping of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for building up the body of Christ, until we all reach the unity of the faith and the knowledge of the Son of God, to a mature man, to a measure of the maturity of the fullness of Christ.” Paul told the Corinthians that each individual member should be concerned with the health of the whole body. He also chided the Corinthians for making the gifts a matter of personal pride.

Now I come to a question for which I may not have an answer. Is there something unique about a spiritual gift, or is it the same thing as a natural talent? I have taught for many years that there is a stark difference between spiritual gifts and talents. Spiritual gifts are supernatural; talents are natural. Spiritual gifts come from the Holy Spirit by His choice at His time; talents come from genetics and experience. Spiritual gifts are empowered from within our spirit; talents are soulish, earthly-powered.

This distinction may not make sense to someone who doesn’t understand the difference between soul and spirit. The New Testament makes it abundantly clear to me that spirit and soul are not just different entities; they are opposed to one another. At one point, Paul says they are opposed to one another. He told the Corinthians that only spiritual works would stand the test of eternity; fleshly, soulish works would be burned up. James called earthly, soulish wisdom demonic while praising the wisdom from above (spiritual) as, “first pure, then peaceful, gentle, obedient, full of mercy and good fruits, nonjudgmental, without hypocrisy.” The contrast couldn’t be more plain.

If this difference between soul and spirit carries through to our giftedness, spiritual gifts and natural talents cannot be the same thing. This difference is easy to see with the so-called miraculous gifts. Paul’s list of gifts in 1 Corinthians lists several: a word of wisdom, a word of knowledge, gifts of healing, miraculous powers, prophecy, distinguishing of spirits, tongues, and interpretation of tongues. His list in Romans may seem more like natural talents: service, teaching, exhortation, giving, leading, and showing mercy. However, these gifts are also, “apportioned by God.”

I admit, there are those who believe that miraculous gifts have ceased to exist. They draw this conclusion from one passage in First Corinthians which they believe predicts the cessation of miracles at the conclusion of the canon of Scripture. There are others who believe that even with the complete revelation of the written Word, there are still occasions for the proper use of supernatural gifts in the church. These people are generally called charismatics, which is curious since that term is a direct transliteration of the word Paul used to describe the gifts of the Holy Spirit which introduces his three-chapter treatise on spiritual things.

It is also curious that churches with a “charismatic” leaning are among the few bodies that are growing these days. This is especially true in Central and South America. I believe that may have something to do with the fact that those opposing Christianity there are steeped in spiritist type religions. It may take a strong spiritual footing to defend the faith and defeat the enemy in those regions. Those of us north of the border may have grown complacent, forgetting that our battle is also spiritual in nature, if not as obviously so. Remember Paul’s claim: “Our struggle is not against blood and flesh, but against… the spiritual forces of wickedness in the heavenly places.”

Recently I heard a sermon extolling the gifted work of church members who were swinging hammers or creating spreadsheets. I tried to imagine spiritual nail pounding or number crunching. I have to admit that any natural talent applied to Christian ministry with proper intent may have spiritual consequences. I struggle to see the use of hammers or pencils as supernatural though. I will have to lean on the idea that we are commanded to do all things to the glory of God, and that if one is led by the Spirit to pound that nail or crunch that number, their gifting might be considered “spiritual” in that context.

My primary spiritual gift is teaching, and when I am doing it at the Spirit’s prompting, I feel a  unique stirring deep within me. I may have to allow that God could give a carpenter or accountant that same experience and qualify their gift as spiritual. The bottom line remains: each believer has a gift from God, and they are commanded to discover it and put it to its proper use. If you are not doing that, you had better have a good excuse ready when you meet the Giver of good and perfect gifts one day.

Related Posts: Music for the Soul; The Christian Parody Part One; Part Two; Part Three; How can we Bless God; Despising the Downpayment

No comments:

Post a Comment